The problem with the Oscars is that movies, like all art, are totally subjective. There’s no real way for movies or performances to compete on a level playing field, because often they aren’t even playing the same sport (a comedy vs. war drama, for example). Besides, who actually takes the large amount of time it would take to watch all the nominated movies (not just best pic noms) to make fair assessments across the board? Hardly anyone.
That’s why the Oscars are really a popularity contest. I mean, sure, skill and great performances are recognized, but since there’s no way to really score the thing, it’s ultimately a popularity contest. Does it really ever make sense for the director of a best picture winner not to win best director? On that note, it seems pretty dumb that this year, Atonement could be nominated in so many categories, including best picture, yet director Joe Wright isn’t one of the best director nominees. Weird. This can be frustrating for a guy who likes sports and movies because in a game, whoever plays better that day wins. It simply cannot work that way for movies.
When I was a young, naïve movie fan, I used to get pumped about the Oscars because at the time, I thought the system really rewarded that year’s best. The year I realized it is actually all about who can mount the best awards campaign was 1998. There is no way Shakespeare in Love is a better “picture” than Saving Private Ryan (more on that later).
Despite the ridiculousness of it all, the Oscars are still fun (minus the political agenda flaunting moments). And it’s always fun to have my own opinion validated on the rare occasion that the Academy picks my favorite. So, in that spirit of fun, here is my list from the past 18 years of the movies that should have won best picture. I’m arbitrarily starting the list with 1989 because that is the year I began paying attention to the Oscars and actually watching a lot of the nominated movies.
1989
Winner: Driving Miss Daisy
Should’ve won: Glory
I don’t mean to crack on Daisy at all. It’s a total classic and I own it on DVD. Any other year in which Glory wasn’t released, Daisy should probably win. But Glory! Man, what a movie. If you’re not on any emotions-affecting medication, I defy you not to get teary at least once sometime during Glory. Glory represents what movies can do better than any other art form. Check out that Denzel guy – not too shabby. How ‘bout that James Horner score? Only one of the best ever. And get this – Glory wasn’t even nominated for best picture, which makes it one of the biggest robberies on my list.
Favorite scene: Too many to choose from. Seriously. Maybe when the regiment marches past the white troops toward the fateful beach. Excuse me while I fetch a hanky…
1990
Winner: Dances With Wolves
Should’ve won: Dances With Wolves
This is one of those movies that’s become kind of a favorite to make fun of over the years. I mean, there’s lots of funny things you can do with the title (and the other Indian names), etc. But the fact remains, this is a great movie and deserved its win that year. Make fun of him all you want, but Costner did a great job acting in this and it’s a little scary how well he did as director, considering it was his first time directing a movie.
Favorite scene: Probably when Dances goes back to his old outpost and finds his journal, reminiscing as he reads, accompanied by a harmonica rendition of John Barry’s beautiful score. Great stuff.
1991
Winner: Silence of the Lambs
Should’ve won: JFK
Lambs is nasty, okay? Yeah, it scared me to death when I finally, entirely reluctantly, caved to my college roomie’s insistence that I needed to see it. I enjoy a great, suspenseful thriller, but not those that glorify their villain’s depravity like Silence. For a superior suspense thriller experience, check out JFK. It’s a complex, twisty tale that leaves your head spinning. Oliver Stone has his politically kooky moments, and I’m not saying this movie closes the book on the assassination – but Stone is a deft movie-crafter and I’ve doubted the lone-gunman story ever since.
Favorite scene: I’ll have to get back to this one later. It’s been too long since I’ve seen it.
1992
Winner: Unforgiven
Should’ve won: A Few Good Men
It turns out that Clint Eastwood is a fantastic director, but this one didn’t win me over. Maybe he won that year because people got all nostalgic about him returning to the Western genre. I just wasn’t moved or all that entertained by Unforgiven. A Few Good Men on the other hand is riveting from start to finish. Its script, by Aaron Sorkin, is simply awesome. The cast is terrific across the board, from headliner Tom Cruise (one of his best performances) to the supporting roles like ol’ reliable Kevin Bacon. For a movie centered around so much talking, it is still ridiculously entertaining.
Favorite scene: This movie has lots of classic lines, so it’s hard to choose. Seems like a cop-out to pick the climactic courtroom scene in which Nicholson accuses Cruise of having difficulty handling the truth, but from the moment Jack takes the stand, the verbal duel between he and Tommy is pretty sweet.
1993
Winner: Schindler’s List
Should’ve won: Schindler’s List
I agree with the Academy that Schindler’s List was the best movie in ’93. It’s very difficult to watch, but it’s one of those movies that everyone needs to see at least once. Its technical aspects are top-notch, everything from the performances to the photography provide it with a rare authenticity that make the experience unforgettable. This movie totally transformed Spielberg’s career.
Favorite scene: It’s very hard to have a “favorite” scene in a movie like this, but I can’t shake the part near the end where Liam Neeson laments not doing more to save more people. It is devastating – just like the whole movie.
1994
Winner: Forrest Gump
Should’ve won: The Shawshank Redemption
Forrest was a box office and cultural phenomenon, so I guess its win was inevitable, but I never really caught Gump fever. It’s not a bad movie. Tom Hanks is great as usual. There are a lot of things I like about it, but overall, it’s not nearly the emotion-grabber that Shawshank is. Actually, I think Quiz Show (another best pic nominee from ’94) is better than Gump too. Apparently if you want a best picture, all you have to do is cast Morgan Freeman. That dude can act. Shawshank is dramatic, sad, humorous, poignant, and suspenseful. It ain’t easy to do all that in one movie.
Favorite scene: Maybe the part where Tim Robbins plays DJ, blaring some classical music in the prison yard.
1995
Winner: Braveheart
Should’ve won: Apollo 13
This is a heretical choice to make among my generation of males. Braveheart is a great movie, a fact confirmed by every sword & sandal dud that has been released in its wake over the past decade, but Apollo 13 got robbed in ’95. Technically awesome, with a great cast and true-story suspense out the wazoo, 13 is movie magic firing on all cylinders. When you consider how complicated the real-life story was, it’s amazing how well Ron Howard and co. translated it for the screen.
Favorite scene: Perhaps when Mrs. Lovell (Kathleen Quinlan) watches a clip on TV of her husband (Tom Hanks) relating a hopeful story about previous in-flight trouble.
1996
Winner: The English Patient
Should’ve won: Jerry Maguire
This is one of the easiest, slam-dunk decisions on my list. Remember that episode of Seinfeld when Elaine keeps referring to it as “that English patient movie”? My feelings exactly. Oh, there are a few okay things about it, but it’s nowhere near Cameron Crowe’s Jerry Maguire for overall entertainment value. Full of classic lines and superior acting from Tom Cruise and Cuba Gooding, Jr., Maguire actually manages to make the “plight” of spoiled, overpaid professional athletes interesting, hilarious, and even dramatic. Maguire is dramedy at its best.
Favorite scene: I really can’t pick just one, so I’ll have to pull one out of a hat… okay, although poor Jonathan Lipnicki was much parodied (not because of bad acting), it’s hard to beat the scene when he gives Jerry a hug and kiss in the kitchen – and just as priceless is Jerry’s uncomfortable expression.
1997
Winner: Titanic
Should’ve won: Amistad
This is one of those years when the Academy started to go off the deep end (pun intended). Titanic was so gigantic that year, you may not have even heard of one of Steven Spielberg’s very best, and one of his least seen, movies called Amistad. For some wacky reason, Amistad wasn’t even nominated for best picture. Based on a true story (yes, I have a penchant for those), Amistad introduced the world to Djimon Hounsou. Hard to believe he had never acted in a movie before. Morgan Freeman and Anthony Hopkins also happen to be in it. It’s another powerful movie from Spielberg about human injustice.
Favorite scene: Easy – when one of Hounsou’s fellow tribesmen explains to him the story of Christ using pictures in a book given them by local parishioners.
1998
Winner: Shakespeare in Love
Should’ve won: Saving Private Ryan
Easily the biggest robbery on this entire list! And the Oscar for best marketing blitz in Oscar history goes to… the Weinsteins. This one still makes me scratch my head. It’s not that I wasn’t semi-entertained by Shakespeare in Love, but there’s just no comparing it to the impact of Ryan. Saving Private Ryan is an experience. I couldn’t shake it for days after first seeing it. I was 21-years-old when I saw it in a theatre and it actually gave me a couple nightmares, which hadn’t happened to me since I was a kid. After hundreds of WWII movies over the years, it’s remarkable that this one felt so original. Its visceral, gut-wrenching violence was a slap in the face for audiences, almost like, “Oh, so this is what the war was really like” – well, not quite, but it’s as close as most of us would ever want to get.
The only consolation here Oscar-wise is that Spielberg did win best director. Oddly enough, he’s still mostly known for his more whimsical movies, but between Schindler’s List, Amistad, Saving Private Ryan, and Munich, I don’t think any director has seriously disturbed me more than Spielberg.
Favorite scene: When Tom Hanks goes off by himself after an intense fire-fight, so his troops won’t see him trying to hold back his emotions.
1999
Winner: American Beauty
Should’ve won: The Straight Story
Anyone who’s read this blog before knows that I’m much more of a mainstream movie fan. So hopefully you know I’m not trying to be all hip and indie by picking The Straight Story for ’99. In fact, just to prove how non-hip I am, it’s still the only David Lynch movie I’ve ever seen!
I really love The Straight Story. Yes, it’s small, and slow, and hardly made anything at the B.O., but it’s all heart, in a non-cheesy, believable way. The three best things on display are Richard Farnsworth, the score by Angelo Badalamenti, and the simple location photography of the American heartland. Required viewing for any American feeling bad about their country.
Favorite scene: Sitting by a campfire, Farnsworth talks about his brother to a priest.
2000
Winner: Gladiator
Should’ve won: Cast Away
Thirteen Days is another great, overlooked movie from 2000, but any movie that can make me emotional (slightly) over a guy losing his best buddy – who happens to be a volleyball, deserves some respect, so Cast Away gets my vote. Gladiator was good spectacle and all, but ultimately felt pretty empty. Cast Away was interesting because it managed to be riveting when most of the movie is just one character talking to himself (and his volleyball friend). I also liked it because it takes you on a turbulent ride back to the real world when Hanks finally escapes the island. It’s a pretty original movie all around and one that stuck with me a lot longer than Gladiator.
Favorite scene: Either the tearful goodbye to Wilson, or the final, hopeful scene at the ranch.
2001
Winner: A Beautiful Mind
Should’ve won: The Fellowship of the Ring
One of the things that annoys me about the Academy is that they’re always retroactively awarding folks. Exhibit A: Ron Howard for Beautiful Mind. Now I’m a pretty big Ron Howard fan. The guy knows how to direct, but this is nowhere near his best movie! Not even close! Where was Oscar when he deserved it back in ’95? Anyway, in my book, it wasn’t even close in 2001 – Fellowship deserved the trophy. I had never read Tolkien’s books and I was very underwhelmed by the trailers, so I was blown away by the Fellowship adventure. Acting, photography, effects, amazing locations, clear-cut good v. evil… what more could you want? A movie’s gotta be pretty good if it can make me care about hobbits. This one did.
Favorite scene: When the fellowship stumbles out of the orc-infested caves, stunned by the loss of Gandalf. The slo-mo sadness really caught me by surprise, and earned my respect. I was hooked on LOTR!
2002
Winner: Chicago
Should’ve won: The Two Towers
In case you think it’s lame to award LOTR two years in a row, a great honorable mention and my other favorite movie of 2002 is About a Boy. But how ‘bout that epic storytelling that is Two Towers! Movies haven’t been this adventurous and cool since I was a kid! It’s awesome for all the same reasons Fellowship is awesome. Chicago over this? Are you kidding me?
Favorite scene: Near the end, when Gandalf sweeps down the mountain with his posse, bringing nick-of-time help to our weary warrior friends.
2003
Winner: Return of the King
Should’ve won: Return of the King
It’s about time! I was beginning to think the Academy had a serious case of hobbiphobia! The thing is, while this pic totally deserved the prize, there were two other best pic noms that year that could’ve been winners most other years: Master and Commander and Seabiscuit, both tremendous flicks! But it was good to finally see the LOTR trilogy rewarded. In a sense, it is one giant movie anyway. Kudos, Pete. I’ll try not to be mad at you for not directing The Hobbit.
Favorite scene: Hard to say, but maybe when Sam summons his inner-Rudy and hustles Frodo up the hill.
2004
Winner: Million Dollar Baby
Should’ve won: Hotel Rwanda
I’m not saying the best picture winner every year has to be a heavy, depressing drama. But what I think of as best picture is something that seriously grabs you in some way and sticks with you long after you leave the theatre. In 2004, that movie was Hotel Rwanda over Million Dollar Baby. The thing is, Baby was almost a great movie. Hillary Swank is great, as is Eastwood and Morgan Freeman (big surprise). Unfortunately, the movie goes way off the deep end in the third act (I won’t ruin it if you want to check it out yourself) and becomes about something completely different. Rwanda on the other hand is consistent throughout in tone. Don Cheadle does an excellent job pulling the audience along on an exhausting, heartbreaking journey.
Favorite scene: Hard to beat the last reunion scene!
2005
Winner: Crash
Should’ve won: Cinderella Man
In my book, Cinderella Man is probably Ron Howard’s best movie. Before its release, I recall hearing some younger folk in the theatre chuckle over the Cinderella part of the title at the end of the trailer. Maybe that was why so many people skipped this gem. This is a rare, unabashedly wholesome, truly American movie. As the title character, Russell Crowe is fantastic as usual. The period details and atmosphere are exquisite. The true story, while pretty straightforward, is still captivating and emotional. You’re probably missing a heartbeat if you don’t get revved by Cinderella Man! It was hands down the best picture of 2005.
Favorite scene: I can’t choose just one, but one possibility is when Crowe shows up, hat in hand, to beg for money from the boxing bigwigs.
2006
Winner: The Departed
Should’ve won: Letters from Iwo Jima
I can admit it when I’m wrong about something and I was definitely wrong about Letters from Iwo Jima. See, I pre-judged the movie when I first read that it was being shot as a sort of companion piece to go with Flags of Our Fathers. I rolled my eyes because I thought it sounded like a hippie, liberal, try-to-understand-the-poor-misunderstood-enemy who bombed Pearl Harbor to smithereens political statement. Sorry I underestimated you, Clint (Eastwood). As it turned out, Letters was poignant, scary, and emotional in ways that Flags didn’t come close to. At the same time, the movie doesn’t try to justify the Japanese position in WWII. I was glad to see it get nominated and it definitely deserved to win.
Favorite scene: The main character’s final scene. I can’t be more descriptive without giving too much away.
Anyway, that’s what I think. Please feel free to post your own opinions!